This is the second blog in which I turn for an expert opinion to Andrew Turner, a seasoned Interim Chief Executive, specializing in change management, business strategy and performance improvement.
Previously, I asked Andrew to set out the three types of interim assignment and he responded:
* Resource-Driven
* Project-Driven
* Change/Solution – Driven
This time, I asked Andrew, based upon his experience to differentiate between an Interim Manager and a Management Consultant. According to Andrew, he views the difference between interims and consultants as follows:
An interim advises, implements, and transfers knowledge.
A consultant mainly advises (and occasionally implements), but retains proprietary knowledge and techniques.
In Andrew’s judgement, the difference between an interim and a contractor boils down to independence, authority, responsibility and scope.
Andrew maintains that the true interim has the ability to act and adapt according to changing circumstances. The interim usually reports to the client Board and has far greater leeway and independent control than a consultant or a contractor. Andrew clarified that the contractor probably reports to a line manager and operates under his control (and subjected to his biases and constraints), with well defined and agreed deliverables, with little wriggle room.
#####################################################################
Finally, I would like to thank the Institute of Interim Management (IIM) for supporting an open debate which prompted Andrew to share the above conclusions. These conclusions are entirely Andrew’s and were neither provided nor necessarily supported by the IIM, nor other members of the debate.
In December 2009, I asked the question on the IIM LinkedIn forum: “How can we help the client and the professional interim match more effectively?”. Apart from myself, participants in the debate included: Ad van der Rest, Tony Evans, Katrina Shepherd, Les Ormonde, Martin Eley, Colin Mclean, Nigel Cole and Tom Pickering.
Reblogged this on Dr Alf's Blog and commented:
Looking back over some of my most popular blogs, I think this is worth a read
Pingback: Reflections on my top 20 blogs in nearly three years of blogging « Dr Alf's Blog
Pingback: Some thoughts on my top twelve blogs out of 2,000+ since Feb 2011? « Dr Alf's Blog
Pingback: Major Coalition projects like aircraft carriers, welfare reforms and broadband roll-out questioned by official Whitehall report – Telegraph « Dr Alf's Blog
Pingback: The Death of the Interim Management Industry? « Dr Alf's Blog
Pingback: Dr Alf Best Twelve Blogs 2011 « Dr Alf's Blog
Pingback: Drawing the Line Closure and Starting Again! | Dr Alf's Weekly Blog
Pingback: Interim Management: Ten Emerging Trends and Outlook for the Future | Dr Alf's Weekly Blog
Pingback: How to Leverage UK Economic Growth: Positive Industry Policies and Deployment of Professional Interims? | Dr Alf's Weekly Blog
Pingback: Four Reasons Why a Professional Interim is a Smarter Choice than a Management Consultant? | Dr Alf's Weekly Blog
Pingback: UK Local Authorities & Shared Services: Cost-Cutting – Myth or Reality? | Dr Alf Oldman's Weekly Blog