Dr Alf poses 5 very difficult questions, which would involve Government doing things which until now they have proved to be incapable of doing. For simplicity, let me restate the questions:
Given the four economic trends in major business namely, declining unionization, rising financialization, technology revolution and globalization, how should Western Governments respond to:
- Take a strategic approach to economic growth, building upon strengths and cutting out public sector waste?
- Ensure effective taxation of profits?
- Increase the skill-base of the nation?
- Deploy the adult population effectively?
- Deploy Scandanavian style social policies?
1) To begin with Governments do not think strategically about anything, let alone economic growth, they do not build on strengths, and they are afraid to cut public sector waste partly because the waste and lack of strategic direction allows too much money to be siphoned off into people’s pockets.
To effect change you have to:
–Reduce public sector jobs by 67% to reflect their poor productivity(32%), and to act as a wake up call to the survivors. This would mean reducing Civil Service numbers to 15000 people, eliminating District and Borough Councils and rationalizing all County Councils, Unitary Authorities, London Boroughs and Metropolitan Borough Councils to 15 for the whole of the UK.
Then, it would mean reducing Constabularies and Fire Commands to 15 for the UK and abolishing all devolved Governments in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, reducing management layers to 5, outsourcing all non-core services and establishing 7 shared services centers for the UK to deal with general enquiries, Adult Social Care pre-assessment, police non emergency dispatching, ambulance dispatching and fire commands.
Those displaced would be banned from the revolving door of interim engagement in any Central or Local Government Department, and from joining Big 4 consultancies and working in the sectors which they have helped to ruin.
If people wanted to retain devolved Government in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland the Barnett Formula would be abolished and these parts of the UK would be granted independence on a “sink or swim ” basis.
MP numbers need to be cut to 200, they would be required to work full-time, have previous business experience and be made to take an IQ test before being put up for election and their housing allowances abolished through the expedient of a Government owned block of flats with full concierge services. Their pay would be a flat £150,000 a year free of all taxes and second homes and expenses would have to come out of that.
Radical restructuring would be applied to the NHS and there would be variable taxes on foods, a bonfire of unnecessary Quangos and the application of smart procurement and independent scrutiny of all public sector accounts, MPs‘ bank accounts, local authority workers bank accounts and the bank accounts of Civil Servants plus the spouses and children/relatives of all of them
2) Effective taxation of profits needs to come by lowered and simplified taxes and the UK becoming a tax haven with a stripped down Monarchy and tightly controlled costs
3) The skill levels of the nation will take decades to improve but it starts with schools,then a French style training levy and until productivity rises much shorter holidays of just 4 weeks including Bank Holidays which are an expensive anachronism.
Faster progress can be made with Paul Scheele style Photo-reading courses which would be run in Further Education colleges at nights and weekends and be made mandatory by employers of full-time staff and by the DWP for benefit recipients who would lose benefit if they refused.
4) The Adult population can only be deployed effectively if there are enough jobs, Business Boot Camps to get people into business and enough exports and foreign inward investment to offset those jobs being lost by technology, robotics and globalised offshoring
5) Scandinavian style social policies are unaffordable for the time being
Dr’ Alf’s five open questions have helped me develop the above “strawman” proposition.
In conclusion, if the UK Government suppresses ineffective ideological policy and goes for radical evidence-based policy, deploying a truly strategic approach to Government, then the UK will once again be the best-in-class standard for effective government, in my judgement.
- Why Dozens of Local Authorities are Collapsing in the UK – John Gelmini (dralfoldman.com)
- A Hard Look at the Implosion of UK Healthcare – John Gelmini (dralfoldman.com)
- Opinion – Betrayal of elderly on social care costs ex Telegraph – John Gelmini (dralfoldman.com)
- Why UK Chancellor George Osborne will not be allowed to use the axe on the Public Sector – John Gelmini (dralfoldman.com)
- Beyond Polly Toynbee’s narrow view on the Labour Party – John Gelmini (dralfoldman.com)
- Understanding the UK NHS’s Terminal Cancer – John Gelmini (dralfoldman.com)
- Radical reform of PFIs – John Gelmini (dralfoldman.com)
- A Hard Look at Why Dozens of Local Authorities are Collapsing in the UK – John Gelmini (dralfoldman.com)
- Cancer in over 65s predicted to treble by 2040 – John Gelmini’s viewpoint (dralfoldman.com)
- Opinion: London’s astonishing boom can lift the whole of Britain – Benadict Brogan ex Telegraph – John Gelmini (dralfoldman.com)
Pingback: Comment: Top 10 causes of death in London boroughs highlight health inequalities|theguardian.com -John Gelmini « Dr Alf's Blog
Pingback: Opinion: Mortgage debt threatens overstretched UK households-FT.com-John Gelmini « Dr Alf's Blog
Pingback: Opinion: The collapse of UK front-line public services under austerity: the case for ABC- John Gelmini « Dr Alf's Blog
Pingback: Opinion: Iain Duncan Smith has lost touch with reality on the Universal Credit – Telegraph – John Gelmini « Dr Alf's Blog