Bureaucrats to return to places of their first posting to assess change on ground – The Times of India

Indian Parliament Building Delhi India

Indian Parliament Building Delhi India (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

This is a truly unbelievable article from the Times of India. It’s a must-read in my view. Check it out!

via Bureaucrats to return to places of their first posting to assess change on ground – The Times of India.

Regular readers of this blog will know that I strongly favor reforming bureaucracies.

Sadly, there is frequently a shortage of strategic analysis in public sector organizations. India probably has some of the most inefficient bureaucracies in the World – perhaps they have lost their way since colonial times?

Of course, the real weakness in India, as highlighted by this story, is the meddling politicians – only when politicians stop meddling will bureaucracies start to become efficient.


Opinion – To make ‘Make in India’ happen, delete control | Times of India Opinion –

English: India Against Corruption Movement log...

English: India Against Corruption Movement logo in SVG format മലയാളം: ഇന്ത്യ അഴിമതിക്കെതിരെ എന്ന പ്രസ്ഥാനത്തിന്റെ SVG ലോഗോ (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

The corruption that is endemic in India that Dr Alf writes about could not flourish without officials, ministers and probably top policemen either being asleep on the job or looking carefully the other way. Show trials of miscreants would just produce some small fish, whilst the real villains walked away scot-free.

Turkeys do not vote for Christmas, so expecting reform from those in charge in that very unequal country is asking too much. Reform can only come when you have different people in charge, and not from the same swamp out of which the present incumbents crawled.

Effectively, you need an Indian equivalent of Lee Quan Yew, someone who is patriotic and willing to root out corruption and malfeasance and willing to take on the Indian version of organised crime, just as Lee Quan Yew did with the Triads and criminal gangs in his native Singapore. This does not mean” Dixon of Dock Green” style policing but something a lot more effective.

The Hindu caste system holds the country back by exaggerating already great inequalities and reinforcing those which already exist. This needs to be challenged by an Indian Government with “cojones”and the sort of” get it done” attitude that the Chinese have. Whether Modi is capable of effecting such change is to me questionable, and until someone capable of rising to the challenge is found, things will not improve very fast.

Longer term, their education system needs to be remodeled along the lines of say South Korea’s and during that long school-day children can have their attitudes reshaped, so that they respect each other and understand what their patriotic duty is rather than accepting corruption, delay and malfeasance as the norm.

John Gelmini