Opinion – Immigration: What have the immigrants ever done for us? | The Economist – John Gelmini

Dr Alf knows that the figures produced on the economic benefits provided by migrants are meaningless.

For example, the NHS would implode if it were not for Indian doctors and foreign nurses; and there would be no council houses at all, if poor Italian immigrants had not been brought to the UK by Harold MacMillan to make the bricks that Englishmen refused to make at the time.

Poles, and other Eastern Europeans, do jobs that the indigenous people in the UK do not want to do, and are incapable of doing as well (based on customer service, attitude, work-rate and productivity).

However, there are extra costs like housing, the need to build better infrastructure, more unemployment among the population here caused by employers preferring immigrants to people from here who have too unhealthy an interest in going on holiday and doing as little work as possible.

Note: UK worker productivity is 16% behind the average for the G7, and there are 47 potential workers for every position which affords UK employers a very wide choice.

Immigrants, like Roma gypsies, and those who deliberately do not learn English, have very large families, multiple wives and dependents, and choose not to work, or engage in crime, benefit fraud and malfeasance clearly represent a net cost to the country. They should be deported or not allowed to come here in the first place.

The UK Government does not know how to properly evaluate the net contribution that an individual immigrant or class of immigrants makes as these questionable figures show.

The UK public are similarly ignorant of the facts and have learned nothing from before the time I was born, but until the Government is prepared to confront them over their lack of productivity and the growing obesity that is one of the main causes of that lack of productivity, the UK will have to have immigrants.

There is a parallel for this.

People in Singapore complained about the number of foreign workers and maids living there. The Minister told them that they had a choice – do the less attractive and menial roles or accept the need for immigrants. Since that adult conversation, people in that successful country accepted what their Employment Minister said. Here, the public are not prepared for that sort of straight talking and the Government is still afraid to confront them or provide real figures that take ALL the factors into account.

John Gelmini

Opinion – ‘My supermarket wage is so low I use a food bank – ringing food through makes me angry’ – Ros Wynne Jones – Mirror Online – John Gelmini

Another interesting post from Dr Alf but no conclusion from the Mirror or indeed anyone else.

There is nothing new in the fact that austerity and cuts fall disproportionately heavily on those at the bottom, particularly those in low wage private sector jobs.

There are essentially 4 problems in the UK which no political party is attempting to address:

1) The austerity when it was applied was too timid and has been going on for far too long.

The maximum period for austerity to be effective as we see with both Canada and Eire is 2 years.

The desired effect has to be a short sharp shock and the wholesale napalming of unessential public sector workers to bring the public sector down to an affordable size.

What has happened is that mendacious Local Authority Chief Executives, Civil Service Mandarins and Local Authority “Service Directorate” heads have all conspired to avoid cuts to their own jobs and have failed to reform anything.

The result is an un-affordable public sector, higher than normal business costs and a squeeze on employment at the bottom.

2) UK worker productivity is now 20th in the world and 16% below the average for the G7.

Employers at Times 1000 Chief Executive level fall into this category as well but set a poor example by paying themselves about 21% more this year versus last year whilst holding down pay for everyone else.

The Government instead of confronting the issue and cutting public holidays does nothing to either address the growing inequality of pay in the country or the fact that bossesx are overpaying themselves without improving corporate performance (We have just 400 world class companies out of 6 million registered at Companies House whereas Germany has 2,500 even with its economy slowing down.

The Government also does nothing to bring errant local authorities to heel and does nothing to curb the growth of civil service numbers which is unwarranted and unsustainable

3) Automation, uncontrolled immigration and much higher productivity from foreign workers now means that there are 47 people chasing each vacancy and that 85% of the vacancies are filled by non indigenous members of the population.

Many of the more menial jobs are done by people from other places because too many indigenous English, Scottish, Welsh and Northern Irish people are not prepared to do them.

This is why the council houses that Harold MacMillan wanted to build had to be made from bricks manufactured by impoverished Italians who were brought into the UK by London Brick Company for that purpose during the 196’s. The 1 million Poles and 1 million Lithuanians, Latvians, Bulgarians, Romanians and other Eastern Europeans now work in hotels, shops, restaurants, farms, pack-houses, distribution centers, the construction industry and a whole host of areas that used to be the province of the C1, C2, D and E social classes that once comprised the “British Working Class”.

Employers want the more hard working and efficient foreign workers not the un-competitive British workers whose lack of productivity has seen the UK lose shipbuilding to the South Koreans, electronics to the Japanese and South Koreans, footwear to the Chinese, toy-making to the Chinese, car manufacturing to Germany , South Korea and Japan, software development to India.

4) The country still fails to make enough of the things that people want or sell enough of those things to bring in enough foreign exchange and very few people in the country at any level understand that the world does not owe us or them a living.

The gap between those at the top of the pile and those at the bottom is set to get wider and until people riot and shareholders start sacking unproductive and overpaid directors nothing will be done.

The odds are stacked against people like this unfortunate woman operating her supermarket checkout because not too long from now even her lowly paid position will be replaced by an automated checkout which means she will have no job at all and will be on the dole.

John Gelmini